[ Apr 18, 2008 ]


American Idol Discussion

After the contestants attempted to recreate Mariah Carey's singing talent, we just had to ask your opinion about the latest Idol-er to get kicked off. Let's say Simon returned to the River Styx where he belongs and American Idol was suddenly on SugarLoot. Who do you think would win?

nugz
Posted by nugz
to For Discussion on Apr 18, 2008
permalink

You are not currently signed in. Please Sign In or Register to comment on this article.

Comments
[ Reply | Report ]
isie "[:"
on the actuall american idol: im glad kristi lee finally went home. shes amazing sure, but shes been in the bottom two so many times!!!

and on sugarloot: who would win? ME! lol jk, who knows? theres a lot of talent on sugarloot :]
Posted 04/18/08 - 10:35am
[ Reply | Report ]
ashlie "(;"
you know, I feel like American Idol was a fad when I was in middle school, it feels a little old to me. lol.
Posted 04/18/08 - 10:38am
[ Reply | Report ]
Elle-doesn't return 's And this is her last contes
I am so glad Kristy Lee got off! She had like no talent!
Posted 04/18/08 - 01:38pm
[ Reply | Report ]
nugz "Circus Isn't That Bad..."
i agree w/ elle. kristy lee needed to be off that show looong ago.
Posted 04/18/08 - 06:39pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Brooklyne "Vote 10s"
Its to hard to say cause theres so many with good talent on here.

But on American Idol it should have been Brooke who got sent home cause the song she did she made it sound boring
Posted 04/18/08 - 06:49pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Logen "boys input needed for blogen"
kristi lee had already been under contract with Britney Spears' and she had to break that to participate, so I was getting tired of hearing the whole...sold the horse story. Maybe she did sell a horse, but she has been around the block already recording music with a label and not sold. I am a David Cook fan. He is brilliant.
Posted 04/18/08 - 09:39pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Emilyy Cullen-VOTE FOR SWIMMM
I LOVE DAVID COOK!!
Haha just thought I'd get that out there, I want him :] He's so cuute!! :P lol
And kristy was sweet, but I think America made the right choice. Go david cooooook! Oh and David A was so cute when he sat down :] What a sweetie!
Posted 04/18/08 - 09:48pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Jalyn Cullen NEW PICTHA
wouldnt it be amazing if next season during american idol, sugarloot had its own american idol contest, with the same standards and like the top twelve? thatd be fabulous!
Posted 04/18/08 - 09:57pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Kello like jello
i think Brooke needs to go, period. She is nice, but sometimes i dont believe the wholle "i dont drink or watch R movies" sort of thing. And she talks was to much when the judges judge her. I loved Micheal, he needs to come back! and i also like Syesha, amazing voice!
Posted 04/19/08 - 12:42pm
[ Reply | Report ]
isie "[:"
i love david cook. end of storyyyyy
Posted 04/19/08 - 02:22pm
[ Reply | Report ]
samantha - back in days
Jason is good but he's gotta go :/ i love brooke & kristi lee [ she could be a model ] and i want her back asappp but for now its between david cook and brooke [ their names rhyme ]
Posted 04/19/08 - 05:56pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Riley "ballet is my life. gah."
jason castro is the best.
i love him :)
Posted 04/20/08 - 01:45am
[ Reply | Report ]
Alyssa-
David Cook has the most talent by far. And is it just me or does Jason Castro always look high when he performs? lol
Posted 04/20/08 - 10:18am
[ Reply | Report ]
Emilyy Cullen-VOTE FOR SWIMMM
Yang I totally agree!! Haha I mean sure, he's still Simon but he's deff warming up :]]
Posted 04/20/08 - 11:02am
[ Reply | Report ]
Sarah "♥"
DAVID ARCHULETA RULES
Posted 04/20/08 - 06:00pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Katie Jo
okay so David A. and David cook are both amazing!!! Also Carly s super great!! I think it should be them in the top three!

Brooke is good but is not idol material.
Jason is okay but not as good as everyone else, he has to go.
Seyesha is very good... but David Cook is gonna win!
Posted 04/20/08 - 07:20pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Taylor is dying for Twilight movie now
David Archuleta is so gonna win. =D He's like the "package" he's cute, young and can sing! =D Again, he's extremely cute!!!!
Posted 04/20/08 - 11:15pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Julia "vote tens for my pug =]"
david cook rockss =D
how old is david a. ?
is he like 17?
Posted 04/21/08 - 04:02pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Emilyy Cullen-VOTE FOR SWIMMM
hurray for davids! :D
yes, david as is 17
awww cutie :]
Posted 04/21/08 - 09:18pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Yvonne "ADD NEW ACCOUNT - READ PROFILE"
Aha, /finally/ Kristy Lee Cook got voted off! She had no talent. :]
Posted 04/21/08 - 09:25pm
[ Reply | Report ]
Hannah
OMG DAVID ARCHULETA IS THEE BEST. His personality is so great, he's cute, and he is such an AMAZING singer!! =]]]]]
Posted 04/22/08 - 05:07pm
[ Reply | Report ]
olivia
i really want david archuleta to win [:
Posted 04/27/08 - 09:20am
[ Reply | Report ]
ayeeee its stacie "ayeee"
omg if jason gets voted off im gonna cry but i guess since its da top 4 now, all dats left is da best so some1 has 2 go...sadly...man i love ALL of them! i love da top 4+ ramielle...those r my favs
Posted 05/07/08 - 08:14pm

You are not currently signed in. Please Sign In or Register to comment on this article.